AdWatch web site
Ken Harvey, School of Public Health, La Trobe University, Melbourne
Healthy Skepticism was originally established in Australia in 1982 as the Medical Lobby for Appropriate Marketing (MaLAM). The organisation maintains a web site containing an excellent (and growing) collection of material about the techniques and impact of pharmaceutical promotion.
AdWatch is a new service established by Healthy Skepticism. It aims to critique particular pharmaceutical advertisements, focusing on both the promotional techniques and the information content. AdWatch comments on how well the claims made by the advertisement fit with the evidence and independent expert opinion. The analysis concludes by making general recommendations about the use of the drug promoted. A feedback form is provided for comments on the analysis.
Nexium (esomeprazole) from AstraZeneca was the first advertisement critiqued by AdWatch, in October 2003. Respondents' feedback was published in December 2003.
AdWatch has just commenced and inevitably there is room for improvement. The site could be improved by better linkage of its materials. In particular, the home page, 'Welcome to AdWatch', lacks the links to 'Introduction' contained on subsequent pages which explain the background to AdWatch. In addition, the home and subsequent pages lacked a link to 'Feedback about the AdWatch prototype' (found on the site map) which had useful correspondence with AstraZeneca staff about the prototype Nexium critique. I suggest that every AdWatch critique should offer the pharmaceutical company involved a space for their response, even if this may not always be forthcoming. AdWatch would provide additional value if it was linked to the National Prescribing Service (NPS) information service (RADAR) about drugs newly listed on the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme (PBS).r1