Optimal use of smoking cessation pharmacotherapy
- Colin Mendelsohn
- Aust Prescr 2022;45:10-14
- 1 February 2022
- DOI: 10.18773/austprescr.2022.001
The most effective intervention for stopping smoking is a combination of professional counselling and pharmacotherapy. Medicines are recommended for all smokers who are motivated to quit and are nicotine dependent.
Combination nicotine replacement therapy with a patch and an oral product is more effective than the patch alone. An adequate dose of nicotine must be used for an adequate duration.
Varenicline is the most effective oral drug. It is safe in people with stable mental illness.
Vaping nicotine is a second-line treatment which can be considered for smokers who are unable to quit with other methods.
Tobacco smoking remains Australia’s leading preventable cause of death and illness, prematurely killing 21,000 people every year.1 At any time, two in three smokers intend to quit.2 Brief interventions by GPs can significantly increase quit rates.3 The most effective intervention is professional support combined with pharmacotherapy.4
All smokers should be offered a brief intervention, such as Ask-Advise-Help. This involves asking all patients if they smoke, advising all smokers to quit and offering treatment or referral.4 If time allows, more detailed support can be given and follow-up visits arranged. Smokers who are ambivalent about quitting may benefit from motivational interviewing.5
Pharmacotherapy is indicated for all smokers who are motivated to quit and are nicotine dependent.4 Their dependence on nicotine can be assessed using the Heaviness of Smoking Index (Table 1).6 The sooner a patient smokes after waking and the more cigarettes smoked daily, the more benefit is generally expected from pharmacotherapy.7
Some smokers are driven more by the smoking ritual and behavioural triggers and less by nicotine dependence. These smokers may benefit from behavioural counselling or vaping, with or without nicotine.8
Table 1 - Heaviness of Smoking Index for assessing nicotine dependence
|Average cigarettes per day||1–10 = 0 points
11–20 = 1 point
21–30 = 2 points
≥31 = 3 points
|Time to first cigarettes (minutes)||61+ = 0 points
31–60 = 1 point
5–30 = 2 points
<5 = 3 points
Nicotine dependence level:
total score 0–2 low, 3–4 moderate, 5–6 high
Table 2 - Efficacy of pharmacotherapy for smoking cessation at 6–12 months
|Drug||Effect size*||Quality of the evidence (grade)|
|Comparison to control or placebo|
|Combination nicotine replacement therapy9||11%||High|
|Single nicotine replacement therapy9||6%||High|
|Comparison to nicotine replacement therapy|
* Effect size is the increase in the efficacy of the drug compared to the comparator
Drugs only have a modest effect on quit rates so it is important to have realistic expectations of treatment. The key to long-term success is to keep trying to quit at every opportunity. For the best health outcomes, the most effective treatment should be used as soon as possible.
If a previous pharmacotherapy was effective and well tolerated, it is generally best to use the same drug again. Other factors guiding the choice of drug include effectiveness, personal preferences, contraindications, drug interactions and cost. Varenicline, bupropion, nicotine patches, gum and lozenges are all available on the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme. However, only one product is subsidised at a time.
Nicotine replacement therapy is the most widely used first-line treatment. It is approved for use by people from the age of 12 years. Nicotine replacement therapy temporarily replaces the nicotine from smoking, reducing cravings and withdrawal symptoms. The nicotine is delivered more slowly than from smoking and monotherapy generally achieves blood concentrations around half those of smoking.13
Two types of nicotine replacement therapy are available:
As nicotine replacement therapy combined with counselling only has a modest effect on quit rates, it is important to optimise its use to increase the chance of success.
Combining the nicotine patch with an oral form of nicotine replacement therapy relieves both background and breakthrough cravings. This is more effective than using a single formulation.14 Combination therapy should be considered for all smokers, especially those who are more nicotine dependent or when nicotine replacement monotherapy has not worked.
Misinformed safety concerns are a major cause of poor adherence.15 Patients should therefore be reassured about the safety and low addictive potential of nicotine replacement therapy. Explain that nicotine does not cause cancer or lung disease and only has a minor role in cardiovascular disease.16 Nicotine replacement therapy is always safer than smoking.16
It is important to give clear instructions on how to use oral products and to review the technique regularly, as most patients use them incorrectly.17 All oral products including the inhalator are absorbed in the buccal cavity. Instruct patients not to eat or drink for 10 minutes before use as this reduces absorption.18
Explain the ‘chew and park’ technique for using gum and the importance of shallow, frequent puffs from the inhalator. Lozenges should be dissolved slowly in the mouth over about 20 minutes. The mouth spray is used under the tongue and swallowing should be delayed as long as possible.
Most patients do not use enough nicotine, often due to misperceptions about safety.17 The dose should be sufficient to control withdrawal symptoms and cravings with frequent review to titrate the dose accordingly. More heavily dependent smokers should use combination nicotine replacement therapy, use 4 mg gum or lozenges instead of 2 mg and they may need two patches.17 Too much nicotine causes nausea, but the risk of toxicity is very low.19
Starting the nicotine patch two weeks before the day the patient intends to stop smoking increases quit rates by 25% compared to starting on the quit day.14
A course of at least 10 weeks is recommended.4 At the end of the course abrupt cessation of nicotine replacement therapy is generally advised as the evidence does not support tapering.14 Extending the course for 12–18 months may help prevent relapse.20
Minor adverse effects are common with nicotine replacement therapy. They vary with the method of delivery (Table 3).
Table 3 - Adverse effects of nicotine-containing products
|Nicotine patch||Skin irritation, redness, itch||1% hydrocortisone|
|Rotate application site daily|
|Insomnia and vivid dreams (24-hour patch)||Use 16-hour patch or remove the 24-hour patch at bedtime|
|Gum, inhalator, lozenge||Dyspepsia, nausea and throat irritation||Avoid swallowing excessively|
|Mouth spray||Throat irritation, hiccups||Delay swallowing|
|Vaping nicotine liquid||Cough, dry throat, nausea, headache||Sips of water for dry throat|
Nicotine replacement therapy is safe in stable cardiovascular disease.21 Oral nicotine replacement therapy is approved in pregnancy with informed consent if behavioural treatment has not been successful, although there is no clear evidence of effectiveness.4 Larger doses are needed as nicotine clearance is accelerated in pregnancy. Nicotine is linked to harmful effects on the fetus in animal studies, but there is no evidence so far of harm to the human fetus. Nicotine replacement therapy can also be used while breastfeeding.4 There are no relevant drug interactions with nicotine replacement therapy. As the pharmacokinetics of some drugs are affected by smoking, check if any dose adjustments are needed when quitting.22
Varenicline is the most effective monotherapy for smoking cessation.9 It blocks nicotine receptors in the brain and relieves cravings and withdrawal symptoms. It also reduces the reward if a cigarette is smoked.
The dose of varenicline is up-titrated over the first week. It should always be taken with food to reduce the risk of nausea. A full course of 12 weeks is recommended and a second course can be considered to prevent relapse.4
There are two ways to take varenicline:
Combining varenicline and a nicotine patch significantly increases quit rates compared to varenicline alone.23 The combination is well tolerated and can be considered if monotherapy has failed.
Adverse effects include nausea (usually self-limiting), headache, insomnia and disturbed dreams.11 Varenicline has no known drug interactions, but is contraindicated in pregnancy and lactation and is only approved for adults. The dose should be reduced in severe renal impairment.
Varenicline is safe and effective in people with stable mental illness.24 Although many patients are reluctant to take it because of reports of depression, behavioural changes and suicidal ideation, there is no definite evidence that varenicline causes these conditions. Everyone who quits smoking is at increased risk of psychological stress, especially those with mental illness.24 All patients who quit smoking should be advised accordingly and monitored for mood or behavioural changes. Advise them to stop varenicline and contact their doctor if there is any concern.
Bupropion is an antidepressant that is also an effective aid for quitting smoking.25 It is taken as an eight-week course with quitting in the second week.
Adverse effects include insomnia, dry mouth and nausea.25 The main risk from bupropion is a one-in-a-thousand incidence of seizures.26 Bupropion is contraindicated in patients with a raised seizure risk and should be used with caution in people taking drugs that can lower seizure threshold, such as antidepressants.26 Pregnancy is also a contraindication.
For smokers who have been unable to quit with other methods, vaping is considered a second-line option.4 It is the most widely used quitting aid globally and in Australia.2 Vaping provides the nicotine that smokers crave as well as the rituals and sensations of smoking, but without most of the toxins and carcinogens from burning tobacco. The cost of vaping nicotine is about 10% of the cost of smoking on average.
The Royal Australian College of General Practitioners (RACGP) guidelines state:4
‘For people who have tried to achieve smoking cessation with first-line therapy (combination of behavioural support and Therapeutic Goods Administration-approved pharmacotherapy) but failed and are still motivated to quit smoking, nicotine vaping products may be a reasonable intervention to recommend along with behavioural support.’
Vaping can be used as a short-term quitting aid, but could have a long-term role for tobacco-harm reduction. Reviews of randomised controlled trials have found that vaping nicotine was about 50% more effective than nicotine replacement therapy.27,28 In absolute terms, six out of 100 smokers will quit with nicotine replacement therapy and 9–10 will quit with vaping nicotine. More studies are needed to confirm the exact effect size. These findings are consistent with those of observational and large population studies.
Vaping is not risk-free, but it is considerably less harmful than smoking.29 Vapour contains low doses of some toxic chemicals such as heavy metals, carbonyls and volatile organic compounds.
Some studies have associated vaping with impaired cell viability, impaired immune defences, increased inflammatory markers, oxidative stress and airways hyper-responsiveness. There is some evidence that vaping may worsen asthma and cause cough and lung irritation in non-smoking adolescents and cause school absenteeism.30 However, asthma,31 chronic obstructive pulmonary disease,32 lung function33 and respiratory symptoms34 can improve when adult smokers switch to vaping.
While the long-term risk of vaping nicotine is unknown, it is unlikely to be more than 5% of the risk of smoking, according to the Royal College of Physicians.29 There is also no evidence of significant harm from passive exposure.29
Patients should be advised that no products are currently approved by the Therapeutic Goods Administration. Short-term use is recommended, but long-term use to prevent relapse to smoking is likely to be far less harmful than relapse to smoking.29 Continuing use of vaping and smoking (dual use) should be discouraged.
It is illegal in Australia to use nicotine liquid without a prescription, but it can be accessed by two legal pathways:
Pharmacotherapy combined with counselling can help smokers quit. The most effective first-line treatments are varenicline and combination nicotine replacement therapy. Vaping nicotine is considered a second-line option for smokers who are unable to quit with other therapies.
Conflicts of interest: Colin Mendelsohn has received funding from Pfizer, GlaxoSmithKline, Johnson & Johnson (Pacific) and Perrigo Australia for teaching, consulting and conference expenses. He is on Pfizer’s Champix Advisory Board.
Dr Mendelsohn has not received any payments from electronic cigarette or tobacco companies. He has a special interest in tobacco-harm reduction and vaping nicotine and was the founding chairman of the Australian Tobacco Harm Reduction Association (ATHRA), a health promotion charity established to raise awareness of safer alternatives to smoking, but is no longer on the Board. ATHRA received funding from the vape industry to establish the charity which was publicly declared. He is the author of a self-funded book called Stop Smoking Start Vaping
This article is peer-reviewed.
General practice, Double Bay, Sydney