The Editorial Executive Committee welcomes letters, which should be less than 250 words. Before a decision to publish is made, letters which refer to a published article may be sent to the author for a response. Any letter may be sent to an expert for comment. When letters are published, they are usually accompanied in the same issue by their responses or comments. The Committee screens out discourteous, inaccurate or libellous statements. The letters are sub-edited before publication. Authors are required to declare any conflicts of interest. The Committee's decision on publication is final.


Letter to the Editor

Editor, The editorial 'Compounding in community pharmacy' (Aust Prescr 2008;31:30-1) outlines concerns that regulators have with the activities of some 'compounding' pharmacists. Regulators are concerned with high-volume (bulk) compounding and the promotion of formulations that are not subject to the same regulations as are applied to the pharmaceutical industry. They do not appear to be concerned with single-unit extemporaneous dispensing of low-risk products.

While we agree that compounding practice standards are in need of review, we believe a risk-management approach should be followed. Uniform adoption of standards that may, for example, demand end-product testing would not seem practical, or necessary, for low-risk extemporaneously prepared products such as creams or lotions.

The prescribing of many compounded medicines is regarded as 'off label'. Consequently, prescribers and dispensers should be guided by contemporary standards for evaluating off-label prescribing.1We believe the guidance for off-label prescribing should be extended for compounded medicines to include the risk-based evaluation and classification of the factors outlined in Table 1.

We suggest a code of practice in compounding which would include:

  • establishing, assuring and maintaining quality through appropriate processes and documentation
  • a risk-management approach (Table 1) to the evaluation of compounded medicines
  • ensuring that prescribers and consumers have current, evidence-based information to support the quality use of compounded medicines
  • complying with therapeutic goods advertising codes and legislation.

These risk-management approaches would support the role of pharmacists in compounding medicines to contemporary standards of quality, safety and efficacy within the spirit of Australia's National Medicines Policy.

Romano A Fois
Lecturer (Pharmaceutics)

Andrew J McLachlan
Professor of Pharmacy (Aged Care)

Barry T Mewes
Visiting Pharmacist

Iqbal Ramzan
Professor of Pharmacy and Dean

Faculty of Pharmacy
University of Sydney

Table 1
A risk-based evaluation of compounded medicines
FactorsRisk criteria
Patient populationIs the medicine to be used in a high-risk population (e.g. children, the frail elderly)?
Site of actionIs the medicine intended to have a local or systemic effect?
IndicationDoes the indication require acute or chronic therapy?
Route of administrationIs the medicine intended for topical, enteral or parenteral administration?
PharmacodynamicsIs there a wide or narrow safety margin (therapeutic index)? Is the dose-response relationship steep or shallow?

Do formulation factors affect the bioavailability or stability of the medicine?

Is the bioavailability highly variable?

Is the complexity of the formulation appropriate for a compounded medicine and is dose-uniformity guaranteed (e.g. in sustained release, transdermal or inhaled formulations)?

Is quality-assurance testing required and can it be performed?


Are the active and inactive ingredients approved for use in Australia?

Have any of the ingredients been withdrawn or rejected from registration because of safety concerns?


Romano A Fois

Lecturer (Pharmaceutics), Faculty of Pharmacy, University of Sydney

Andrew J McLachlan

Professor of Pharmacy (Aged Care), Faculty of Pharmacy, University of Sydney

Barry T Mewes

Visiting Pharmacist, Faculty of Pharmacy, University of Sydney

Iqbal Ramzan

Professor of Pharmacy and Dean, Faculty of Pharmacy, University of Sydney